New Jobs
Massive Software Outage Paralyzes Hospital EMRs, 911, and Systems Globally - Nurse.org CNA / NAC All shifts - 5,000 SIGN ON BONUS job in Sequim, WA - Nurse.org This Week's Health IT Jobs – July 17, 2024 | Healthcare IT Today Why Becoming a Nurse Coach Was My BEST Career Move National jobless rate edges upward slightly in June - Medical Economics 100% Of Nursing Faculty Resign From Dickinson State University - Nurse.org In the Know: Bridging the gap between military personnel and civilian careers - Echo Press High-Paying Medical Jobs Without NEET: Your Pathway to Success - Education Times Financial Coordinator | Lehigh Valley Health Network If You Have Any Of These 13 Jobs, Your Career Might Vanish In 5 Years - PharmaciePageot OHSU reveals a second wave of job cuts | HealthLeaders Media Enhance medical coding precision and efficiency and upskill with the CAIMC - WCBD Job Search Portal MEDICAL RECORDS CODER 2 Job Opening in Dallas, Texas - AHIMA Career Assist Eyeing a healthcare career? Here are the trending roles, skills and pay brackets you should know iRCM Inc: Trusted Experts in End-to-End Medical Billing and Credentialing Services Nationwide University Hospitals to cut 300+ jobs, including some VP, C-suite roles 8 cities with the most job opportunities in AI health care - Medical Economics New educational programs will help meet Southwest Florida's health demands Certifications Overview | AHIMA The 4 Highest-Paying Industries For Entry-Level Jobs - Forbes Administrative Assistant/Trainee Clinical Coder, Colchester, Essex - Forces Families Jobs<... This Week's Health IT Jobs – June 12, 2024 | Healthcare IT Today 20 Top Healthcare Companies in Chennai | Built In 5 Best States for Remote Jobs: Working From Home Locations | First For Women BSN to DNP-PH Public Health - Nursing - Herzing University CTC to host free medical billing and coding event | Education - The Killeen Daily Herald Medicare Advantage plan's quality ratings were incorrectly calculated by government, judge rules Study shows mental health, lack of workplace support as key factors driving nurses away from ... Nurse Practitioner - Advanced Practice Provider job in Tempe, AZ Students use Washtenaw Community College as a gateway to healthcare careers Top Healthcare Certifications Worth Pursuing For Career Advancement - WJBF Medical Coding Specialist Certified - Part Time (Dual Posting) job with University of ... Medical coders are in great demand as healthcare becomes increasingly data-driven 3 Reasons I Chose to Pursue a Career in Healthcare - Herzing University The CAIMC® - Certified AI Medical Coder: Elevating Medical Coding to the Next Level 6 educational programs that will help you retrain and find a job in New York Launching Your Health Care Career: 5 Entry-Level Jobs at URMC Embracing Your Power as a Nurse Leader List: 6 training programs in NYC helping New Yorkers gain jobs - Yahoo Free medical billing and coding course at adult school - Moorpark Acorn Clinical Coder II – Student Health Care Center (CHFM) (531665) - Careers at UF Medical Coding Market: Prospective Growth Trends and Incremental Opportunity ... - WhaTech India's First Job Pass: Unlimited Access to Top Courses for BTech, MBA, Pharmacy & Biotec... Healthcare Scheduling Specialist- Part Time Medical Records Technician (HIT) HIM DATA INTEGRITY SPECIALIST - MEDICAL RECORDS Senior Medical Secretary Medical Scribe Medical Transcriptionist I
News

Covid Immunity Through Infection or Vaccination: Are They Equal?

Dr. Aaron Kheriaty, a University of California-Irvine psychiatry professor, felt he didn’t need to be vaccinated against covid because he’d fallen ill with the disease in July 2020.

So, in August, he sued to stop the university system’s vaccination mandate, saying “natural” immunity had given him and millions of others better protection than any vaccine could.

A judge on Sept. 28 dismissed Kheriaty’s request for an injunction against the university over its mandate, which took effect Sept. 3. While Kheriaty intends to pursue the case further, legal experts doubt that his and similar lawsuits filed around the country will ultimately succeed.

That said, evidence is growing that contracting SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes covid-19, is generally as effective as vaccination at stimulating your immune system to prevent the disease. Yet federal officials have been reluctant to recognize any equivalency, citing the wide variation in covid patients’ immune response to infection.

Like many disputes during the covid pandemic, the uncertain value of a prior infection has prompted legal challenges, marketing offers and political grandstanding, even as scientists quietly work in the background to sort out the facts.

For decades, doctors have used blood tests to determine whether people are protected against infectious diseases. Pregnant mothers are tested for antibodies to rubella to help ensure their fetuses won’t be infected with the rubella virus, which causes devastating birth defects. Hospital workers are screened for measles and chickenpox antibodies to prevent the spread of those diseases. But immunity to covid seems trickier to discern than those diseases.

The Food and Drug Administration has authorized the use of covid antibody tests, which can cost about $70, to detect a past infection. Some tests can distinguish whether the antibodies came from an infection or a vaccine. But neither the FDA nor the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommend using the tests to assess whether you’re, in fact, immune to covid. For that, the tests are essentially useless because there’s no agreement on the amount or types of antibodies that would signal protection from the disease.

“We don’t yet have full understanding of what the presence of antibodies tells us about immunity,” said Kelly Wroblewski, director of infectious diseases at the Association of Public Health Laboratories.

By the same token, experts disagree on how much protection an infection delivers.

In the absence of certainty and as vaccination mandates are levied across the country, lawsuits seek to press the issue. Individuals who claim that vaccination mandates violate their civil liberties argue that infection-acquired immunity protects them. In Los Angeles, six police officers have sued the city, claiming they have natural immunity. In August, law professor Todd Zywicki alleged that George Mason University’s vaccine mandate violated his constitutional rights given he has natural immunity. He cited a number of antibody tests and an immunologist’s medical opinion that it was “medically unnecessary” for him to be vaccinated. Zywicki dropped the lawsuit after the university granted him a medical exemption, which it claims was unrelated to the suit.

Republican legislators have joined the crusade. The GOP Doctors Caucus, which consists of Republican physicians in Congress, has urged people leery of vaccination to instead seek an antibody test, contradicting CDC and FDA recommendations. In Kentucky, the state Senate passed a resolution granting equal immunity status to those who show proof of vaccination or a positive antibody test.

Hospitals were among the first institutions to impose vaccine mandates on their front-line workers because of the danger of them spreading the disease to vulnerable patients. Few have offered exemptions from vaccination to those previously infected. But there are exceptions.

Two Pennsylvania hospital systems allow clinical staff members to defer vaccination for a year after testing positive for covid. Another, in Michigan, allows employees to opt out of vaccination if they present evidence of previous infection and a positive antibody test in the previous three months. In these cases, the systems indicated they were keen to avoid staffing shortages that could result from the departure of vaccine-shunning nurses.

For Kheriaty, the question is simple. “The research on natural immunity is quite definitive now,” he told KHN. “It’s better than immunity conferred by vaccines.” But such categorical statements are clearly not shared by most in the scientific community.

Dr. Arthur Reingold, an epidemiologist at UC-Berkeley, and Shane Crotty, a virologist at the respected La Jolla Institute for Immunology in San Diego, gave expert witness testimony in Kheriaty’s lawsuit, saying the extent of immunity from reinfection, especially against newer variants of covid, is unknown. They noted that vaccination gives a huge immunity boost to people who’ve been ill previously.

Yet not all of those pushing for recognition of past infection are vaccine critics or torchbearers of the anti-vaccine movement.

Dr. Jeffrey Klausner, clinical professor of population and public health sciences at the University of Southern California, co-authored an analysis published last week that showed infection generally protects for 10 months or more. “From the public health perspective, denying jobs and access and travel to people who have recovered from infection doesn’t make sense,” he said.

In his testimony against Kheriaty’s case for “natural” immunity to covid, Crotty cited studies of the massive covid outbreak that swept through Manaus, Brazil, early this year that involved the gamma variant of the virus. One of the studies estimated, based on tests of blood donations, that three-quarters of the city’s population had already been infected before gamma’s arrival. That suggested that previous infection might not protect against new variants. But Klausner and others suspect the rate of prior infection presented in the study was a gross overestimate.

A large August study from Israel, which showed better protection from infection than from vaccination, may help turn the tide toward acceptance of prior infection, Klausner said. “Everyone is just waiting for Fauci to say, ‘Prior infection provides protection,’” he said.

When Dr. Anthony Fauci, the top federal expert on infectious diseases, was asked during a CNN interview last month whether infected people were as well protected as those who’ve been vaccinated, he hedged. “There could be an argument” that they are, he said. Fauci did not immediately respond to a KHN request for further comment.

CDC spokesperson Kristen Nordlund said in an email that “current evidence” shows wide variation in antibody responses after covid infection. “We hope to have some additional information on the protectiveness of vaccine immunity compared to natural immunity in the coming weeks.”

A “monumental effort” is underway to determine what level of antibodies is protective, said Dr. Robert Seder, chief of the cellular immunology section at the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases. Recent studies have taken a stab at a number.

Antibody tests will never provide a yes-or-no answer on covid protection, said Dr. George Siber, a vaccine industry consultant and co-author of one of the papers. “But there are people who are not going to be immunized. Trying to predict who is at low risk is a worthy undertaking.”

This story was produced by KHN, which publishes California Healthline, an editorially independent service of the California Health Care Foundation.

KHN (Kaiser Health News) is a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about health issues. Together with Policy Analysis and Polling, KHN is one of the three major operating programs at KFF (Kaiser Family Foundation). KFF is an endowed nonprofit organization providing information on health issues to the nation.

USE OUR CONTENT

This story can be republished for free (details).

Syndicated from https://khn.org/news/article/covid-immunity-through-infection-or-vaccination-are-they-equal/